Debunking the EQ Myth: Why Boosting Frequencies is Completely Valid
Click HERE to Watch the YouTube Video
In the world of audio production, equalization (EQ) is a powerful tool for shaping sound, whether in music, film, or any audio medium. A common debate, however, centers on whether boosting with EQ is “wrong” or even possible. A viewpoint out there insists you should only cut frequencies—not boost—because supposedly, boosting tries to add something that isn’t there in the original signal. Let’s dive in and clarify why this claim is misleading, what boosting with EQ actually does, and how to apply these principles practically in your own mixing projects.
What EQ Boosting Really Means
To start, boosting with EQ doesn’t create new frequencies; it merely increases the volume of certain frequency bands within the original signal. Think of EQ as a series of volume faders, each linked to a specific frequency range. When you boost a frequency, you’re not adding an entirely new sound—you’re making what already exists in that frequency range louder and more present in the mix.
This concept can be visualized easily with a graphic EQ. When adjusting the “faders” on specific frequency bands, you’re not altering the fundamental structure of the sound. You’re simply making certain parts of the sound spectrum stand out more or become quieter, depending on your mixing needs.
Addressing the “Phase Shift” Myth in EQ
Phase shifting is another common concern when boosting frequencies with EQ, and it's true that EQ inherently introduces some degree of phase shift, whether you boost or cut. This is simply part of how EQs operate. However, when working with a single instrument, these phase shifts are rarely noticeable or problematic. They are just a natural byproduct of equalization.
I tested this myself by applying a “null test” to a duplicate track. Here’s how it worked: I took the same audio file, applied a 2 dB boost in the low frequencies on one version, and a 2 dB cut at the same frequencies on the duplicate. After level-matching the tracks and reversing the polarity on one of them, the audio completely canceled out. This result showed that the phase shift remained identical on both versions. The takeaway? Boosting with EQ doesn't introduce any additional phase shift beyond what’s already there.
How Boosting and Cutting Affect Sound Perception
In practice, EQ is all about balance. For instance, if you’re trying to add clarity to a track, you could boost the high frequencies slightly to emphasize brightness. Alternatively, you might cut certain low-mid frequencies to achieve a similar effect without adding any extra volume to the highs. Both approaches change the perceived clarity and balance of the sound but in slightly different ways.
The goal in mixing is to consider the EQ changes in the context of the entire mix. Instead of aiming to “add” new content with EQ, think of it as adjusting the volume and presence of what’s already there to create a balanced, cohesive sound.
The Real Way to Add Frequencies: Harmonic Distortion
While EQ itself cannot create new frequencies, harmonic distortion can. This effect is common with analog gear, tube amps, and plugins designed to emulate analog characteristics, such as saturation or tape emulation plugins. When you use distortion or saturation, additional harmonics—essentially, new frequencies—are generated, which can add a unique color or warmth to the sound.
Analog-style EQs often add subtle harmonic distortion to a signal, resulting in a different sonic character compared to a clean digital EQ. These differences might be slight, but they can contribute to a richer, more complex sound that many find appealing.
When and Why to Boost (or Cut) with EQ
The decision to boost or cut should ultimately serve the mix as a whole. If boosting a frequency adds clarity, fullness, or any quality you want in the track, then go for it! Remember, it’s not about adding something that wasn’t originally in the signal—it’s about highlighting or downplaying the parts that are already there.
As a practical tip, when you find yourself making several cuts across the EQ spectrum, consider whether a simple volume adjustment might be just as effective. Resetting everything to zero and lowering the overall volume can often lead to more subtle EQ adjustments, creating a smoother, more natural sound.
Final Thoughts
Using EQ effectively is about understanding its role as a tool to shape sound. Whether boosting or cutting, you’re working with what’s already in the audio, adjusting it for clarity, balance, and cohesion within the mix. And if you do want to add something “new,” harmonic distortion is the answer—EQ isn’t designed for that job.
By mastering EQ, you’re not just enhancing sounds; you’re bringing the whole mix together in a way that feels complete and polished. Keep exploring, experiment within your mixes, and embrace EQ’s role in audio production. Happy mixing!